Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
Ethnocultural Aspects of Refugees and Survivors of Torture
  • Ricardo Restrepo, M.D
  • Michael A. Grodin, M.D


  • Boston Center for Refugee  Health and Human Rights


  • Boston University Schools of Medicine and Public Health


2
Definitions
    • Refugee
    • Internally displaced people
    • Uprooted people
    • Systematic Violence
    • Crimes Against Humanity
    • Genocide
    • Disappeared person
    • Returnee
    • “Torture”



3
“Our Secret” by Isabel Allende
4
Outline

    • Definitions
    • The Refugee Today
    • Cultural Perspective
    • Interviewing the Patient
    • Final Recommendations
    • Vicarious Traumatization


5
World Refugee Survey 2001
6
Refugee Worldwide
7
Internally Displaced
8
Internally Displaced Worldwide
9
Uprooted People
10
Uprooted People
11
Uprooted People Worldwide
12
Leading Sources of Uprooted People
13
World View of Uprooted Population
  • 57 Countries are Sources of
  • Significant Uprooted Population
14
World Refugee
  • 94 Countries are  Either Producing or
  • Hosting Significant Numbers of Uprooted People.
15
An Example: Africa
16
Systematic Violence
    • All human rights violations: torture, ill treatment, genocide, crimes against humanity
    • Carried out purposefully and regularly
    • Governments, state sanction groups or individuals
    • Against political, religious, or ethnic groups
    • Affecting well-being of individuals



17
Crimes Against  Humanity
    • Law No. 10 International Military Tribunal
    • Atrocities and offenses against civilian population including but not limited to
    •     - Murder, extermination, enslavement, deportation, imprisonment, torture, and rape
    • Whether or not in violation of domestic laws

18
Genocide

  •     Any act with the intend to destroy (in whole or in part) a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group
    • Killing
    • Bodily or mental harm
    • Conditions to bring physical destruction
    • Measures to prevent births
    • Forcibly transferring children

19
Disappeared Person

    • Any person arrested, detained, abducted or otherwise deprived of liberty
    • Refusal to disclose the fate or whereabouts of the person
    • Placing that person outside the protection of the law


20
Returnee

    • Any refugee, internally displaced person, asylum recipient/seeker


    • Able to return to place of residence


21
Torture
  •  UN Convention Against Torture, 1984
    • Any act, physical or mental, intentionally inflicted
    • Purposes: information, confession, punishing, intimating, coercing, discrimination



  • WHO: Declaration of Tokyo, 1975
    • Deliberate, systematic, or wanton
    • Physical or mental suffering
    • Information, confession, any other reason



22
Common Methods of Torture
23
Outline
    • Definitions
    • The Refugee Today
        • Epidemiology
        • People at Risk
        • Treatment Options
    • Cultural Perspective
    • Interviewing the Patient
    • Final Recommendations
    • Vicarious Traumatization
24
Epidemiology
25
Epidemiology

    • Women and children represent 90% of refugees and Internally displaced people
    • Currently 30 armed conflicts
    • Civilians now represent 90% of casualties



26
Epidemiology
Prevalence of Torture
27
People at Risk
28
Treatment options
  • Specific interventions
    • primary medical care
    • psychotherapy
    • social services
    • spiritual resources
    • medications
    • physical therapy/ massage
29
Factors Needed in The Refugee Assessment
30
Outline

    • Definitions
    • The Refugee Today
    • Cultural Perspective
    • Interviewing the Patient
    • Final Recommendations
    • Vicarious Traumatization
31
Stages in The Refugee Experience
32
Stages in The Refugee Experience
33
Trauma in Cultural Perspective
34
Trauma in Cultural Perspective
35
Trauma in Cultural Perspective
36
Important Cultural Factors
37
Individual’s Aspects
38
Medicalization of Trauma
39
Survival Mechanisms
40
Expressions of Vulnerability after Trauma
41
Resilience
42
Cultural Manifestation of Trauma
43
 Expression of Trauma
44
The Black Box in Somatization
45
The Black Box in Somatization
46
 
47
Somatization
48
Cross Cultural Considerations in Mental Health
49
Cross Cultural Considerations in Mental Health
50
Cross Cultural Considerations in Mental Health
51
Cross Cultural Considerations in Mental Health
52
Cross Cultural Considerations in Mental Health
53
Outline

    • Definitions
    • The Refugee Today
    • Cultural Perspective
    • Interviewing the Patient
    • Final Recommendations
    • Vicarious Traumatization
54
 Interviewing the Patient
    • Boston Center for Refugee  Health and Human Rights
    • The setting
    • The process
    • Interpreters
    • Education



55
Geographical origin
56
Gender
57
Types of Torture
58
Prevalence of Health Problems
59
Outline

    • Definitions
    • The Refugee Today
    • Cultural Perspective
    • Interviewing the Patient
    • Final Recommendations
    • Vicarious Traumatization


60
Interview – The Setting
61
Interview – The Process
62
Interview – Interpreters & Education
63
Outline

    • Definitions
    • The Refugee Today
    • Cultural Perspective
    • Interviewing the Patient
    • Final Recommendations
    • Vicarious Traumatization


64
Guidelines to Respond to Cultural Diversity
  • Assess the importance of ethnicity to patients and families
  • Validate and strengthen ethnic identity
  • Be aware of and use the patient’s support systems
  • Serve as a “culture broker”
  • Be aware of “cultural camouflage”
  • Know that there are advantages and disadvantages in being of the same group as your patient
65
Guidelines to Respond to Cultural Diversity
  • Do not feel that you have to “know everything” about your patient
  • To avoid polarization, always try to think in categories that allow for at least three possibilities
66
Outline

    • Definitions
    • The Refugee Today
    • Cultural Perspective
    • Interviewing the Patient
    • Final Recommendations
    • Vicarious Traumatization


67
Vicarious Traumatization
  • Accumulates over time and across clients


  • Different from effect of therapy work in general


  • Produces symptoms of Post Traumatic Stress


  • Changes view of oneself and the world
68
Vicarious Traumatization
  • Generalized anxiety
  • Numbing
  • Overwhelmed
  • Poor coping
  • Anger
  • Intrusive thoughts


  • Nightmares
  • Irrational fears
  • Addictions
  • Sleep disturbances
  • Dissociative reactions
  • Intrusive images


69
Vicarious Traumatization
  • Loss of sense of safety
  • Loss of trust
  • Loss of connection with others
  • Despair
  • Cynicism
  • Disillusionment
  • Incapacity for intimacy
  • Poor self-esteem
  • Loss of sense of control
70
Thanks!!