Oral Health
Types of Torture
Blunt trauma
Blunt trauma can be divided into three categories: crushing injuries,
whipping, and beatings (1-4).
Fingers and genitalia are frequent targets for crushing injuries.
Objects commonly used include riffle butts, pliers, heavy rollers,
or even the body weight of the perpetrators. Common sequelae of
crushing injuries include fractures, dislocations, ankylosis, and
deformed limbs.
Classic whip marks are easy to recognize by their appearance—multiple
thongs or thin lines. When victims are often flogged with belts,
wires, leather ropes, or bamboo canes, however, non-characteristic
marks may be present. Whipping usually produces only transient and
superficial marks that fade away within days. If permanent marks
remain, they can appear as hyperpigmented macula or ill-defined
scars.
Beatings are one of the two most common forms of torture, the other
being threats (4, 2). Certain forms of beatings have received specific
names. For instance "telefono" (the telephone) consists
of hitting both ears simultaneously with the palms of the hands.
Such trauma may cause hearing loss by rupturing the tympanic membranes.
Beating the soles of the feet with a solid object is called "falanga,"
which has the purpose of disabling the victim and preventing him
or her from escaping. The resultant soft tissue swelling frequently
may cause a compartmental syndrome serious enough to cause necrosis
of the feet. Although perpetrators have their victims wear socks
or footwear during "falanga" to prevent lacerations and
permanent scarring, these foot coverings do not prevent the compartmental
syndrome (1, 5-7).
Beatings may produce a wide range of physical marks. Some marks
are transient, such ecchymosis, that resolve within one or two weeks.
Others are permanent, including scarring, fractures, or deformed
limbs (1,5-7). In general, the long-term external sequelae of beatings
do not reflect the severity of a beating. For instance, a beating
may cause acute renal failure from rhabdomyolysis, yet leave only
small superficial scars or no permanent physical marks.
|
Crushing Injury
Comparative view of index fingers showing a deformity of the
distal phalanx of the right finger caused by smashing with the
butt of a rifle. |
 |
Whipping
Whipping of a prisoner with a bamboo cane in Southeast Asia
(Courtesy of Physicians for Human Rights) |
Penetrating Injuries
Penetrating injuries are produced by gunshot wounds,
flying shrapnel from explosions, and stabbing—which includes
slash and scratch cuts.
Perpetrators typically shoot their victims in
the lower limbs to prevent any possible escape (7). Most gunshot
wounds cause serious injuries, such as palsy or fractures, and potentially
life-threatening conditions like hemorrhages or perforation of a
hollow viscera. Death may occur from bleeding or direct damage to
a vital organ. Long-term complications include palsy, limb deformity,
and organ dysfunction.
Objects used for stabbing include, but are not
limited to needles, razor blades, knives, bayonets, and various
sharp objects such as glass, scrap metal, and rods. Forms of stab
wounds include amputations of earlobes, fingers, and toes, and slash
cuts (5). Stabbings may cause pain, bleeding, nerve damage, perforation
of a hollow viscera, and infection. Death may occur from bleeding
or septicemia from a infected wound or a ruptured hollow viscera.
As with beatings, the long-term sequelae of a stab wound do not
reflect the severity of the causal insult.
 |
 |
Flying Shrapnel
Anterior-posterior and lateral views of the skull showing metallic
shrapnel from a projectile. |
|
Stabbing: Slash Cuts
Slash cuts of the interior aspect of the left arm. |
Suspension
Victims of torture may be suspended by their wrists
or ankles for several hours or even days (4-5,7). Tightening
ropes may compromise circulation to hands or feet. Some victims
experience permanent neurological damage from nerve compression. Resulting
scars from prolonged suspensions are easy to identify: bilateral
scars or maculae around the wrists or ankles. Frequently,
victims are suspended as high as possible and then released suddenly,
causing different forms of blunt trauma such as bruises, fractures,
and dislocations. Perpetrators also suspend their victims
transiently from the earlobes, which may cause their avulsion, or
the hair, causing traumatic alopecia (4-5,7). Male victims
of torture may also endure a form of suspension in which heavy
objects
are hung from their genitalia.
Certain forms of suspension have received specific
names. "La barra” (the rod), is also called the chicken
or the wheel of Buddha, consists of tying down the wrists with the
ankles while keeping the knees completely flexed. A rod is passed
under the knees and in front of the elbows, and then the victim
is suspended by lifting the rod (5,7).
"La bandera" (the flag) consists of
tying down both wrists on the back of the victim and then suspending
the person by the hands. This type of suspension produces intense
pain and as soon as muscular fatigue ensues, shoulders dislocate,
damaging the brachial plexus.
"The Palestinian suspension" consists
of suspending the victim with one hand facing forward and the other
one facing backwards. As with "la bandera," this type
of suspension produces intense pain and eventually produces shoulder
dislocation and brachial plexus injury (7).
Finally, "el quirofano" consists of
leaving the upper half of the victim’s body suspended in the
air, while the victim is laying down and facing up. "El quirofano"
produces muscle spraining in the lumbar area (5).
Burns
Victims of torture may endure chemical, thermal,
and electric burns. A wide variety of objects are used to inflict
this type of injury: cigarettes, hot irons, gas torch, ice, hot
liquids like water and oil, electricity from power outlets or stunt
guns, acids, and other caustic materials (1-11).
|
Burns
Anterior aspect of the right foot showing a flash-over burn
from a grenade explosion. |
Asphyxiation
Perpetrators asphyxiate their victims by covering
their faces with a plastic bag (dry asphyxiation or dry "submarino"),
submerging their faces in fluids (wet asphyxiation or wet "submarino"),
and by forcing their victims to inhale chemicals or dust. In
general, filthy water, urine, or excrements are used to carry out
the wet "submarino" (1-11).
|
Asphyxiation
Asphyxiation of a prisoner during human experimentation at
the Dachua Concentration during the Holocaust. |
Electric Shocks
Electric shocks are commonly used in South America
and Africa. Sources of electric shocks include power outlets,
portable
generators, cattle probes, and stunt guns (1-11). Electric probes
are often placed on sensitive organs, such as earlobes and genitalia.
Long-term physical marks from electric shocks are typically discrete
and minor, although some victims may experience a permanent seizure
disorder. In contrast, the immediate complications of electric
shocks are potentially lethal: tonic-clonic seizures and cardiac
arrhythmias.
Forced Human Experimentation
During the Nuremberg Trials, physicians were indicted,
tried, and convicted for committing crimes against humanity, including
forced human experimentation. Although the Nuremberg Code prohibits
forced human experimentation, health professionals continue to participate
in such activities. Unfortunately, the participation of health
professionals in torture goes beyond forced experimentation and
includes engaging in torture or in its cover-up by giving false
medical certificates (12).
Traumatic Removal of Tissue and Appendages
Earlobes, hair, and nails are often removed traumatically.
In addition, an explosive wave may produce avulsion of soft tissues.
Extreme Physical Conditions
Victims of torture recount several different forms
of extreme conditions. Many victims have endured detentions inside
prison cells where a human being only fits squatting, as well as
exposure to adverse climatic conditions without shading, water,
or appropriate clothing. Others have been forced to remain standing
or assume difficult postures for days without rest (1-11).
Sexual Torture
Sexual torture includes sexual humiliation (e.g.
pejorative comments), trauma to genitalia (e.g. suspension of heavy
objects from the genitalia, castration, instrumentation), and rape.
The international Crime Tribunals for Rwanda and
the former Yugoslavia charged rape as a war crime. Rape
is used effectively to terrorize entire communities. In Rwanda
and the former Yugoslavia, for instance, women were frequently
raped in front of relatives or their communities, leaving them ostracized,
repudiated by husbands and other relatives.
Sexual torture produces long-lasting mental and
physical sequelae. In rape cases, these include unwanted pregnancy
and sexual transmitted diseases.
Mental Torture
Almost all victims of torture suffer some form
of mental torture. Direct threats to him/her or to a relative are
by far the most common form of torture. Other forms of mental
torture include sensory deprivation, poor conditions during detention,
mock executions, long interrogations, and being forced to torture
another person, witness the torture of another person, or watch
killings and rapes. Sensory deprivation includes detention
in complete darkness, exposure to bright lights and constant noises,
or sleep deprivation. Lack of food, potable water, toilet, bed,
windows, aeration, medical care, and communication are examples
of poor conditions during detention (1-11).
Mental suffering unique to refugees include enduring
battlefield conditions, uprooting, and life in a refugee camp (1-11).
Summary: Most Common
Types of Torture (1-11) |
1. Blunt Trauma: crushing injuries,
whipping, beatings
2. Penetrating Injuries: gunshots, shrapnel, stab wounds, slash
cuts
3. Suspension
4. Burns: chemical and thermal, cold and heat
5. Asphyxiation: wet, dry, chemical
6. Electric Shocks
7. Forced Human Experimentation
8. Traumatic Removal of Tissue and Appendages: via either direct
avulsion or explosion
9. Extreme Physical Conditions: forced body positions (prolonged
constrain) and extreme heat/cold conditions
10. Sexual Torture: sexual humiliation, trauma to genitalia,
rape
11. Mental Torture: direct threats, sensory deprivation, solitary
confinement, mock execution, witnessing torture, uprooting
|
References:
1. Shrestha NM and Sharma B. Torture and Torture
Victims – A Manual for Medical Professionals. Center for Victims
of Torture, Katmandu, Nepal, 1995.
2. Mcivor RJ and Turner SW. Assessment and Treatment Approaches
for Survivors of Torture. British J. Psychiatry 1995;166: 705 –
711.
3. Forrest D. The Physical After-Effects of Torture. Forensic Science
International 1995; 76: 77 – 84.
4. Petersen HD and Rasmussen OV. Medical Appraisal of Allegations
of Torture and the Involvement of Doctors in Torture. Forensic Science
International 1992; 53: 97 – 116.
5. Rasmussen OV. Medical Aspects of Torture. Danish Medical Bulletin
1990; 37(Supplement 1): 1 – 88.
6. Goldfeld AE, Mollica RF, Pesavento BH, Stephen VF. The Physical
and Psychological Sequelae of Torture – Symptomatology and
Diagnosis. JAMA 1988; 259(18): 2725 – 2729).
7. Skylv G. Physical Sequelae of Torture. In: Basoglu M (Ed.). Torture
and Its Consequences – Current Treatment Approaches. Cambridge
University Press: Cambridge, UK, 1992. p 39 – 53.
8. Sommier F, Vesti P, Kastup M and Genefke IK. Psychosocial Consequences
of Torture: Current Knowledge and Evidence. In: Basoglu M (Ed.).
Torture and Its Consequences – Current Treatment Approaches.
Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, 1992. p 56 – 68.
9. Weinstein HM, Dansky L, and Iacopino V. Torture and War Trauma
Survivors in Primary Care Practice. West J Med 1996; 165: 112 –
118.
10.Iacopino V, Ozkalipci O, Schlar C. Manual on the Effective Investigation and Documentation of Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (The Istanbul Protocol). Available at: http://www.phrusa.org/research/torture/index.html [Accessed 05/11/01].
11. American College of Physicians. The Role of the Physician and
the Medical Profession in the Prevention of International Torture
and in the Treatment of its Survivors. Ann Int Med 1995;122: 607
– 613.
12. Annas GJ and Grodin MA. The Nazi Doctors and the Nuremberg Code
- Human Rights and Human Experimentation. Oxford University Press,
New York, NY; 1992.
|